Order online from Gotham Bagels South Loop, including Bagels & Deli, Sandwiches, Extras. Tilly Bagel Shop makes excellent sourdough bagels in creative flavors like cacio e pepe. Location. Madison. m. Bagels, Sandwiches, Delis $$ 520 S Plymouth Ct, Chicago, IL 60605. ” more. I've been to Manhattan and I've had the bagels, and yes, they're pretty good. Gotham Bagels - South Loop. Each bagel is fluffy and chewy, with a thin, lightly blistered crust. it is super annoying to have. Previous. Top 10 Best Bagels Near Greenwood, South Carolina. I wish there was one in Seattle! Date of visit: June 2017. Hotels. Sandwiches. Salmon Lox Bagel. Nearby Restaurants. and Will C. Enjoy a freshly-made treat on the go or take some home to share with your family. Sort:Recommended. South Loop Bagels, Sandwiches, Delis 0. 3 earn points, get rewards. 3 earn points, get rewards. We would hate to give you too much (unless you don’t mind), and we would hate to short you. 2. Stan’s Donuts. There’s no pre-ordering here, and you’ll usually find six daily options like everything, sesame, pretzel, cheddar jalapeno pretzel, with specials like spinach and artichoke. There's something for everyone, from traditional favorites to unique combinations. daily. Chicago, IL 60605. 2, 2023, at 34 E. Gotham Bagels Magnificent Mile, 162 E. “Nice new store with appealing displays of a variety of cream cheeses, pastries and salads. Gotham Bagels - South Loop. In the United States, the best bagels are probably in New York…and Madison, Wisconsin, and Chicago, Illinois, because it’s in those three locations that you’ll find bagels made the traditional way, served fresh, never frozen, firm yet fluffy, the bagels of dreams. Last Name. It’s originally from Madison, Wisconsin (not exactly known for its bagel prowess), and runs its carryout operation from a nondescript window behind the Gino’s East in the South Loop. Elite 23. This family-owned business has seven locations and bakes 10,000 bagels a day, but you can see its passion for homemade bagels and cream cheese in every store. Choose to email or print. Improve this listing. Bagels, Chicago Bagel AuthorityBoth tasted great! I highly recommend Gotham Bagels for brunch and catering parties! See all photos from Linda A. 520 S Plymouth Ct, Chicago. Bagels, The Great American Bagel, Grounds of. Chicago, IL. Cute little shop with a homey decor. Order Online Your Order. Rate your experience! Bagels. comBagels in South Bend, Indiana South Bend, Indiana is home to some of the best local places for tasty breakfast treats. I love getting an everything bagel w smoked salmon, scallion cream cheese red onion, cucumbers, and tomatoes. 43 reviews of Tilly Bagel Shop "An official welcome to Tilly Bagel Shop in the South Loop! I've had the pleasure of enjoying their bagels at farmers markets over the summer, and I am thrilled they now have a storefront. We offer gourmet sandwich creations, house smoked white fish, thin sliced pastrami, and premium smoked salmon. Mon. Bagels, The Bagelers Coffeehouse, Gotham Bagels - Magnificent Mile , El Bagel, Schneider Deli, Gotham Bagels. LOCATIONS - BLOG - CONTACT - MEDIA - PRESS MENTIONS. The Bagel Blog. First Name. , Sunday 8 a. Open 8am to 2pm every day! As of now, Gotham. Gotham Bagels Sun Prairie has closed but a new restaurant is coming in under the reins of a longtime employee. 2. You have to order off the internet. Funny. Bagels, Farmhouse Coffee, Lil Coffee Cabin, Great American Bagel, Gotham Bagels - South Loop, Tilly Bagel ShopTo get started, choose your favorite Gotham Bagels location. 2 225 N Michigan Ave (at Lake St), Chicago, IL Bagel Shop · The Loop · 11 tips and reviews Duane Wheatcroft: Best bagels in the building. 9 am - 1 pm In Madison: 112 E. Bagels, Bagels Time, Gotham Bagels"I love Gotham Bagels in Lakeview!" Jeanne G. Gotham Bagels: Definitely NOT a Quick Bite or a Pop-in/Pop-out Bagel Shop - See 63 traveler reviews, 3 candid photos, and great deals for Madison, WI, at Tripadvisor. There is a little area outside you can sit at too that's cute". chicken liver mousse, bacon, pomegranate, caramelized onions, sourdoughGotham Bagels: Bad Attitude - See 62 traveler reviews, 3 candid photos, and great deals for Madison, WI, at Tripadvisor. Bagels Near Me. ” more. Gotham Bagels - South Loop. 32To get started, choose your favorite Gotham Bagels location. The bagel wasn't toasted, which was probably a good thing. - Sun. m. There's something for everyone, from traditional favorites to unique combinations. Finally! Great NYC style bagels in Chicago! annnd, they’ve got that Matzah Ball Soup! 🥯 🥯 🥯 All bagels are NOT the same. Connecticut. Umai is my favorite restaurant in the south loop, starting with that. 2. Guaranteed to Arrive Fresh. 2500 W. Contact Info. Gotham Bagels in Loop (near Harold Washington Library-State/Van Buren Harrison LaSalle Metro Station): details with ⭐ 26 reviews, 📞 phone number, 📅 work hours, 📍 location on map. Share. The best bagels in the Midwest. Top 10 Best Bagels in Chicago, IL 60608 - November 2023 - Yelp - Schneider Deli, Corey’s NYC Bagel Deli, Gotham Bagels - South Loop, Tilly Bagel Shop, Chicago Bagel Authority, Foxglove Coffee, Gotham Bagels, The Great American Bagel, Brobagel, L Cafecito Jumping Bean Price: $1. ” more. From asiago to cinnamon & raisin bagels, you can find all types of. Homespun Bagels. 782. Magnificent Mile. Gotham Bagels, Madison: See 62 unbiased reviews of Gotham Bagels, rated 4 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #275 of 859 restaurants in Madison. 3 photos. Gotham proudly offers the best bagels in Chicago, using tried & true techniques to hand roll their authentic NYC bagels. Sunday. 1 review of Bagels Time "my office use them for a big breakfast meeting today and i cant tell you great bagels great service very prompt will use them again soon". LAKEVIEW — Chicago-based Bravo Restaurants has closed its Gino’s East pizzeria in Lakeview and opened a hybrid restaurant selling New York-style bagels during the morning and Italian food at night. 225 N Michigan Ave (at Lake St), Chicago, IL. With a prime location, classic Chicago style pizza, and an expansive craft beer list, you can't go wrong with Gino's East in the South Loop. The Daly Bagel. Best Bagels in Pilsen, Chicago, IL 60608 - Tilly Bagel Shop, Gotham Bagels - South Loop, Hero Coffee Bar, The Great American Bagel, Einstein Bros. July 2, 2020. Gotham is a fantastic carryout bagel spot in Old Town. 07/22/2022 Gotham Bagels . We're proud to offer one of Chicago's biggest bagels - great with one of our. While it doesn’t advertise as a New York bagel joint—probably due to some of the nontraditional ingredients. 2 stars. Closed now : See all hours. Best Bagels in S Wentworth Ave, Chicago, IL - Einstein Bros. 35 minute wait to put 2 bagels in a bag - Gotham Bagels. Our bagels are the best in the Midwest rolled, boiled, and baked to perfection. Found a new favorite bagel place on the SW side of town. Madison Tourism Madison Hotels Madison Bed and Breakfast Madison Vacation Rentals Flights to Madison Gotham Bagels; Things to Do in MadisonGotham Bagels: Once Loyal Customer stiffed w/Raw Deal - See 61 traveler reviews, 3 candid photos, and great deals for Madison, WI, at Tripadvisor. See more reviews for this business. Whether you're looking for a classic bagel, beigel, bun, roll, doughnut, muffin, pastry, bismarck, bagel bite, bagel sandwich, pletzel, or pretzel, you'll find it in the Scenic City. 61 reviews "Apparently no one told Gotham Bagels there’s a vaccine for Covid. Gas. Coffee. 0. Tilly Bagel Shop. (Brian Cassella/Chicago Tribune) She plans to offer 12 flavors of bagel each day, along with. 322 reviews. Gotham Bagels - South Loop « Back To Chicago, IL. 8. Moe’s Broadway Bagel, Boulder and Denver. Ask Denise B about Gotham Bagels. 19 mi. “Used to enjoy these bagels at the farmer's. Gotham Bagels - South Loop. Paul Bagelry. THE BEST 10 Bagels in 50 W Washington St, Chicago, IL 60602 - September 2023 - Yelp - Corey’s NYC Bagel Deli, Gotham Bagels - South Loop, Schneider Deli, Gotham Bagels - Magnificent Mile , Tilly Bagel Shop, Hero Coffee Bar, Einstein Bros. ” more. Poppy. Our bagels are the best in the Midwest rolled, boiled, and baked to perfection. Find the best bagels around Chikaming, Michigan and get detailed driving directions with road conditions, live traffic updates, and reviews. Call. ® Bagels is your neighborhood bagel shop. All restaurants in Madison (984) Been to Gotham Bagels? Share your experiences!Gotham Bagels: They Don't Have NYC Water But. to 2 p. Gotham Bagels offers gourmet sandwich creations, hand-rolled bagels, deli selections (including house smoked white fish, thin sliced pastrami, traditionally mixed tuna fish salad, latkes, and premium. Gotham Bagels South loop « Back To Chicago, IL. . 04 mi away. Best Breakfast & Brunch in South Loop, Chicago, IL 60605 - Yolk - South Loop, Wildberry Pancakes and Cafe, Honey Berry Pancakes and Cafe, Sweet Bean, Grant Park Bistro, Lasalle Cafe Luna, Eleven City Diner, Hero Coffee Bar, Half Sour, Gotham Bagels - South Loop Best Bagels in 225 S Canal St, Chicago, IL 60606 - Gotham Bagels - South Loop, Corey’s NYC Bagel Deli, Rye Deli & Drink, Hero Coffee Bar, The Great American Bagel, Einstein Bros. Bagels, The Great American BagelBest Bagels in 8394 W 300 N, Michigan City, IN 46360 - El Bagel, Broad Street Cafe, Biggby Coffee - Michigan, Studebagels, Gotham Bagels - South Loop, The Bagelers Coffeehouse, Einstein Bros. Good fruitcake have an appetizing taste. Established in 2009. Gotham Bagels - South Loop. You have no items in your cart. Chicago Ave. Park St. Gotham Bagels - Magnificent Mile . Cool. "Eleven City Diner in the South Loop is pretty good too. Enjoy a freshly-made treat on the go or take some home to share with your family. 2 ORDER ONLINE. Phone: 467-7833. A nice woman confirmed that my order was next to be fulfilled. You have no items in your cart. Gotham Bagels - South Loop. On Fridays, they sell loaves of freshly baked challah, which definitely wins us over. - See 61 traveler reviews, 3 candid photos, and great deals for Madison, WI, at Tripadvisor. m. Gotham Bagels, Madison: See 61 unbiased reviews of Gotham Bagels, rated 4 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #299 of 941 restaurants in Madison. 9 - 60 votes. Address 2: 5426 Nicollet Ave, Minneapolis, MN 55419. “I love bagels and when it said New York style, hand rolled bagels I wanted to try them for sure!” more. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Gotham does it right. Top 10 Best Best Bagels in The Loop, Chicago, IL - October 2023 - Yelp - Tilly Bagel Shop, Corey’s NYC Bagel Deli, Schneider Deli, Gotham Bagels - South Loop, Hero Coffee Bar, Goddess and the Baker, 33 S Wabash-Millennium Park, Gotham Bagels, Chicago Bagel Authority, Miru, Dollop CoffeeA breakfast bagel sandwich sure but a bagel containing lettuce, avocado and tomato? That's just gross. Top 10 Best Best Bagels in The Loop, Chicago, IL - October 2023 - Yelp - Tilly Bagel Shop, Corey’s NYC Bagel Deli, Schneider Deli, Gotham Bagels - South Loop, Hero Coffee Bar, Goddess and the Baker, 33 S Wabash-Millennium Park, Gotham Bagels, Chicago Bagel Authority, Miru, Dollop Coffee A breakfast bagel sandwich sure but a bagel containing lettuce, avocado and tomato?. Trusted by 2,000,000 members Verified. agree. SIGN UP FOR BAGEL NEWS Stay in the loop with all things Gotham Bagels! We promise not to spam your mailbox. Madison Tourism Madison Hotels Madison Bed and Breakfast Madison Vacation Rentals Flights to Madison Gotham Bagels; Things to Do in Madison Madison Travel ForumThick, chewy, and loaded with cream cheese, they’re unlike anything you’ll find in other states—until now. ” more. Madison Tourism Madison Hotels Madison Bed and Breakfast Madison Vacation Rentals Flights to Madison Gotham Bagels; Things to Do in MadisonEarn 3x points with your sapphire card. Best Bagels in Pilsen, Chicago, IL 60608 - Tilly Bagel Shop, Gotham Bagels - South Loop, Hero Coffee Bar, The Great American Bagel, Einstein Bros. Monroe St. Website: St. Madison Tourism Madison Hotels Madison Bed and Breakfast Madison Vacation Rentals Flights to Madison5. , the shop serves warm, crunchy bagels filled with fried, runny eggs, a half-dozen varieties of cream cheese and thin-sliced, thick-stacked pastrami ($10). We're proud to provide our guests with freshly baked bagels, breakfast sandwiches, coffee and much more. Wawaka, Indiana is home to some of the best local places for tasty breakfast treats. That's all you need here and in life. Order New York Dozen Bagels (13) online from Gotham Bagels South Loop. There's something for everyone, from. “I just feel if you get a bagel to-go that you plan to eat on the go. Gotham Bagels South Loop is located in Chicago, IL. 1212 North Dearborn Street. Bagels, Gotham Bagels, Chicago Bagel Authority Both tasted great! I highly recommend Gotham Bagels for brunch and catering parties!. Top 10 Best Gotham Bagels in Chicago, IL 60605 - October 2023 - Yelp - Gotham Bagels, Gotham Bagels - South Loop, Gotham Bagels - Magnificent Mile , Gotham Bagels - Lakeview , Corey’s NYC Bagel Deli, Hero Coffee Bar, RL Restaurant. “I had a multigrain bagel with egg whites, spinach and cheese. I’d rather pay the price of a legit sandwich and get a breakfast. 35. Morgan Street Cafe. Bagel shop. Do-Rite Donuts & Chicken. THE BEST 10 Bagels in 50 W Washington St, Chicago, IL 60602 - September 2023 - Yelp - Corey’s NYC Bagel Deli, Gotham Bagels - South Loop, Schneider Deli, Gotham Bagels - Magnificent Mile , Tilly Bagel Shop, Hero Coffee Bar, Einstein Bros. But after spending countless hours traversing the city and. Order Online Your Order. 3-8oz Wagyu beef patties, 4-bratwurst, 4-uncured hot dogs, Any dozen bagels with spreads, NY Deli Salads, 8oz each: Macaroni, Potato, Roasted Red Peppers, Coleslaw, Gotham's Finest pickles, Chicago Jonny's hot Giardiniera and 32oz Sucker Punch Bloody Mary Mix; Jumbo Shrimp Salad. Bagels, Delis, Sandwiches. Top 10 Best Lox and Bagels in Chicago, IL - November 2023 - Yelp - El Bagel, The Bagelers Coffeehouse, Schneider Deli, New York Bagel & Bialy, Steingold's of Chicago, Gotham Bagels - South Loop, Taste Of New York Bagels & Deli, Gotham Bagels - Lakeview , Tilly Bagel Shop, Chicago Bagel Authority Best Bagels in Michigan Ave, Chicago, IL - Gotham Bagels - South Loop, Tilly Bagel Shop, Corey’s NYC Bagel Deli, Einstein Bros. Gotham Bagels - South Loop. Egg. House whipped cream cheese Gotham Bagels South Loop - Cream Cheese 8ozAugust 14, 2023 Save to a list It's a universally held truth that Chicago's bagel scene can't compete with New York's. Top 10 Best Bagel Sandwich in Chicago, IL - November 2023 - Yelp - El Bagel, The Bagelers Coffeehouse, New York Bagel & Bialy, Brobagel, Chicago Bagel Authority, Perkolator, Gotham Bagels - South Loop, Cracked on Milwaukee, Gotham Bagels - Lakeview , Taste Of New York Bagels & Deli We offer the best breakfast, brunch, and lunch catering in Chicago! Catering from Gotham Bagels in Chicago is perfect for your next corporate get together, brunch at home, or other event! Order bagels a la carte or with fixings for breakfast & lunch sandwiches. Get the best prices and service by ordering direct! Gotham Bagels Chicago Order online from Gotham Bagels South Loop, including Bagels & Deli, Sandwiches, Extras. Spread Bagelry (multiple locations) Spread’s Montreal-style bagels are hand-rolled, boiled in honey water, and baked in a wood-fired brick oven. Exp:Nov 1, 2023. Abel's bagels on Durango. All. Gotham Bagels, Chicago: See 2 unbiased reviews of Gotham Bagels, rated 4. By providing your phone number, you are agreeing to participate in the rewards program and to be contacted through this number as part of the program. Korean. Best Bagels near Soldier Field - Tilly Bagel Shop, Gotham Bagels - South Loop, Gotham Bagels - Magnificent Mile , Hero Coffee Bar, Corey’s NYC Bagel Deli, Schneider Deli, Bagels Time, Rye Deli & Drink, The Great American BagelGotham New York Bagels and Eats. 1. Order Online Your Order. The Great American Bagel, 1154 West Madison St, Chicago, IL 60607, Mon - 6:00 am - 3:00 pm, Tue - 6:00 am - 3:00 pm, Wed - 6:00 am - 3:00 pm, Thu - 6:00 am - 3:00 pm, Fri - 6:00 am - 3:00 pm, Sat - 6:00 am - 3:00 pm, Sun - 6:00 am - 3:00 pm. Gotham Bagels - South Loop. Big Apple Bagels. Photo by Gotham Bagels (Show full size) Similar Businesses Nearby. madison & chicago. “I love that their bagels have evaded the American tendency to jack up portion sizes to twice what. Claim now to immediately update business information and menu! Nearby Eats. More Details. That being said, the bagels are so dang good that we keep coming back. 65 votes, 10 comments. Bacon Egg and Cheese. Overall rating. . Our Featured Menu. In the south-central section of the great state of Wisconsin in between two shimmering lakes there lies a truly unique and spectacular gem of a city. Turkey Sandwich. 4. Bagels. Gotham Bagels’s Tweets. The fast-growing chain already has 10 locations in and. Madison. Find the best bagels around Salt Creek, Indiana and get detailed driving directions with road conditions, live traffic updates, and reviews. 3. Madison Tourism Madison Hotels Madison Bed and Breakfast Madison Vacation Rentals Flights to Madison Gotham Bagels; Things to Do in Madison Madison Travel ForumTop 10 Best Bagels Near Sacramento, California. Top 10 Best Kosher Deli in The Loop, Chicago, IL - November 2023 - Yelp - Manny's Cafeteria and Delicatessen, Corey’s NYC Bagel Deli, Bockwinkel's, The Corned Beef Factory Sandwich Shop, Gotham Bagels - South Loop, Eleven City Diner, Mariano's - Lakeshore East, Gold Coast Market, Helfeld's. Funny. 4. They come in interesting flavors like cacio e pepe or a rotating special like pepperoni pizza. Food. Gotham Bagels . Send by email or mail, or print at home. Ruby’s New York Style Bagels - Mount Pleasant. 112 E Mifflin St, Madison, WI 53703-2825 +1 608-284-7145 Website. Comments. Reheating Instructions. 50 each, and speciality bagels are $4, Tillett said. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. More in Chicago; Edit Place; Force Sync. and Nathan M. Best Bagels in 814 N Wells St Chicago IL 60610 - Coreys NYC Bagel Deli Gotham Bagels The Bagelers Coffeehouse Rye Deli Drink Gotham Bagels - South Loop Chicago Bagel Authority Bebes Kosher Deli Coreys NYC Bagel Deli Brobagel. Gotham Bagels - South Loop 3. Mifflin & NEW deli at 702 S. I ordered the everything bagel with scallion cream cheese, topped with avocado and a fried egg. There's something for everyone, from traditional favorites to unique. Top 10 Best Lox and Bagels in Chicago, IL - November 2023 - Yelp - The Bagelers Coffeehouse, El Bagel, New York Bagel & Bialy, Schneider Deli, Taste Of New York Bagels & Deli, Steingold's of Chicago, Helfeld's Delicatessen & Catering, Gotham Bagels - South Loop, Gotham Bagels - Lakeview , Chicago Bagel AuthorityBest Bagels in Michigan Ave, Chicago, IL - Gotham Bagels - South Loop, Tilly Bagel Shop, Corey’s NYC Bagel Deli, Einstein Bros. That’s what you’ll get at a lot of places in NYC, and in the two. ), Chicago, IL. TILLY BAGEL SHOP. The best bagels in the Midwest. 1212 North Dearborn Street. See more reviews for this business. Whether you're looking for a classic bagel, beigel, bun, roll, doughnut, muffin, pastry, bismarck, bagel bite, bagel sandwich, pletzel, or pretzel, you'll find it in the Scenic City. Web site: gothambagels. 62 reviews "Today is foodie day and my daughter wanted to start her day with a bagel. Half Dozen Bagels. Their location in the south loop has been my top bagel place, but I haven't been able to go with the blue line train under construction. Located around the back of Gino’s East in the South Loop, you. A bagel and coffee joint. Food. Whether you're looking for a classic bagel, beigel, bun, roll, doughnut, muffin, pastry, bismarck, bagel bite, bagel sandwich, pletzel, or pretzel, you'll find it in the Scenic City. The food is great and the staff are very friendly. Food. Gotham Bagels Chicago. Madison Tourism Madison Hotels Madison Bed and Breakfast Madison Vacation Rentals Madison Vacation PackagesTrying to score bagels from Gotham Bagels is like trying for a presale for a concert. 0 (59 reviews) Bagels Sandwiches Delis $$ Printer's Row. The new bagel shop will feature handcrafted sourdough bagels and cream cheese. Bagels, El Bagel, Gotham Bagels, Brobagel, Bagels TimeSpecialties: As seen on The Profit. This amounts to 0. Funny. The Beanery. I've been to Manhattan and I've had the bagels, and yes, they're pretty good. Mon: Closed Tues-sat: 8am-2pm sun: 8am-12pm. Search reviews. Ginos East - South Loop Pizza, Sports Bars 0. Sarah Kutz June 9, 2023. Fave. Coffee Mug. Search MapQuest. 15. 18 photos. A La Carte Entrees. 288. offers catering. She just has so many positive memories with NY bagels, from. Bagels Deli. Hotels. " Arriana V. Quick Lunch - Eleven city, Devil dawgs, roots, shang noodle. Madison Tourism Madison Hotels Madison Bed and Breakfast Madison Vacation Rentals Flights to MadisonGotham Bagels South Loop Look up rewards account Please insert the email address or phone number associated with your account and we will get in touch with your account details. 15. Sign Up. Mapbox. (312) 656-8166. There is an outstanding selection of. With those naysayers gone, let me continue. Only does on-line ordering, and the QR code on the menu was for a different location. To check out the full and updated menu, click “Order Now” and choose your favorite location!Best Bagels in The Loop, Chicago, IL - Gotham Bagels - South Loop, Corey’s NYC Bagel Deli, Tilly Bagel Shop, Bagels Time, Schneider Deli, Gotham Bagels - Magnificent Mile , Hero Coffee Bar, Gotham Bagels, Einstein Bros. Enjoy a freshly-made treat on the go or take some home to share with your family. It’s originally from Madison, Wisconsin (not exactly known for its. This boutique bakery specializes in intricate, show-stopping cakes and other sweet treats, but they turn out Best of Philly-worthy bagels, too. Gotham Bagels - South Loop. Sort:Recommended. Julio: Try a Bagel with peanut butterReviews on Bagels in 900 S Wells St, Chicago, IL 60607 - Gotham Bagels - South Loop, Hero Coffee Bar, Corey’s NYC Bagel Deli, Manny's Cafeteria and Delicatessen, Cafe Press ChicagoFrequently Asked Questions for Gotham Bagels. Regular bagels start at $3. Always make sure you call ahead to check opening hours, because schedules can change and may not be updated in realtime. Got a cinnamon raisin. 1. Fried egg, aged cheddar, & thick cut bacon. On paper, Gotham might not seem like a likely candidate for having some of the city’s best bagels. Indiana Ave. Top 10 Best Bagels Near Charleston, South. And a super nice woman carefully packaged my bagels and spread, walking my bagels and super divinely hot coffee to me with zest and kindness. Gotham Bagels . 308 Reviews Madison, WI . Get the best prices and service by ordering direct!. Gotham Bagels - South Loop. Scott Kleinberg: Cinnamon crunch bagel, vanilla roast coffee. Pease@evrealestate. Restaurateur Jordan Himmel missed the hand-rolled New York–style bagels he ate at Gotham Bagels when he was a student in Madison, Wisconsin, so this spring he decided to bring them south and. Best Bagels in Spartanburg, SC - Sully's Steamers, Broadway Bagels, Katie D's New York Bagels & Deli, Jersey Bagel Brothers, Riverside Bagels & Deli, Southern Fuel And Coffee, Wildflour Bake Shop. The “Cacio e Pepe” bagel at Tilly Bagel Shop. m. The operation is inside the Eduardo’s Enoteca kitchen. Tradition! Years of learning the little secrets and tricks of making the perfect New York bagel, passed down from bubbe to bubbe. Closed Now. madison & chicago. Bagels & Deli as low as $3. 01 mi away. Madison. I’ve seen them posted many times on the sub so I decided to try a bacon egg and cheese from gotham for the first time today…Gotham Bagels, Madison: See 63 unbiased reviews of Gotham Bagels, rated 4 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #295 of 856 restaurants in Madison. We’re open for online orders. The super bready bagels at Northern Liberties' The Kettle Black are the best in the neighborhood.